The other night over a very interesting dinner with 3 bloggers and 5 communications professionals, we started talking about regulations within our respective industries. The FTC recently published a new, half thought-through set of regulations for pushing products through social media channels. For instance, if you are tweeting, posting, and writing about a product on your site, you have to disclose whether or not a company compensated you to write about your experience with their good. The bloggers have a direct relationship with these new rules and were explaining the complexities.
I thought to myself while the conversation progressed, here lies yet another addition to the list of rules that we are asked to play by. Everyday the papers are littered with stories about bills, proposals, and requests for more regulation. From the banking system and the private insurance companies, to immigration and education, the FDA, EPA, ABA, PTA, NCAA ... all want tighter rules, heavier sanctions, and more control.
I have always played by the rules and am honestly afraid to go against them. When authority figures tell me to do something, I do it, and for the most part, no questions asked. I grew up in a household (the daughter of a lawyer mind you) where there were codes of conduct and certain sanctions for not abiding by the house rules. There was room for interpretation amongst my siblings and I; and there became various strains of tolerance from the parental unit for deviating from the rules; but on the whole, my siblings and I grew up following by the system. From my perspective here are seven rules that I thought to be unbreakable in the Fischer household:
Rule #1: Everyone pitches in around the house
Rule #2: Everyone is nice to each other
Rule #3: Everyone is clear about where they are going, who they are going with, and when they will return
Rule #4: Everyone goes to church together
Rule #5: Everyone partakes in the family activity and doesn't fuss about it
Rule #6: Whatever the parent says, goes
Rule #7: If mom or dad had a stressful day at work, take heed of bad mood and suck up as much as possible
I held these guidelines as the law and was petrified of repurcussions had I not followed them. I always did whatever chore I needed to do without complaint. I told my parents exactly where I was going and with whom ( I even had a self-imposed curfew so my parents wouldn't be able to find any fault in my weekend activities.) If my parents wanted to attend 8 AM mass on Sunday, I was there by their side. I lauded whatever family outing we chose, jovially sauntering through flower shows, art museums, folk festivals, and grocery stores as my siblings scoffed at my syrupy enthusiasm.
My siblings had a different take on the rules though. My elder sister had her own opinion and wasn't afraid to share it. She took many long bathroom breaks after dinner aleviating her from dish duty. Despite getting in trouble for it, she continued to go on Eat N' Park outings with Midnight Mary Anne in our Transport van. My brother threw out some of these rules in high school when his sense of reasoning developed. He used to tell my parents he would no longer field their intrusive questions, that he was leaving to go out with an undisclosed group of friends, and that he would go to mass later alone. From my perspective such risky behaviors were unthought of. Looking back on it, what possessed me to be so law abiding and for lack of a better word, such a dork?!
I don't know why I am so into following the rules. It wasn't just my parents rules either. I used to become extremely nervous (and actually start crying) as the "We will be closing in 30 ... 10 ... 5 minutes" announcement echoed through the Home Goods section of Kaufmanns while late night shopping with my mother. I was afraid that we would break the rules, get locked in the store, and then my life would be over. Again, looking back on it, how exciting would it have been to get locked in a department store at night?! The ultimate slumber party with my Mom and sister would have unfolded complete with giant beds dressed with perfect bedspreads, new PJs and robes, makeovers, televiewing on giant screens, and eating our way through displays of rich Godiva chocolate.
Today we face debate after debate in our country about stricter rules and heavier sanctions. And though it may be a stretch, I want to compare the different perspectives of rules in the smaller governed body of my family to a larger governed body like America.
Though I have always been creative and have a unique personality, I get anxious when asked to break a rule. I can think outside the box, but I am often afraid to work and play outside the box. My siblings on the other hand were never afraid to test boundaries with authority figures. Their reasoning and confidence led them to believe that, perhaps, at times, the way the authority wants us to do things isn't the best way. Perhaps there is another way, a better way. My parents managed both sides very well - gathering new sets of information from my elder sister who was actually reading books during those "bathroom breaks", getting chores done around the house through me, and getting endless amounts of laughter from my brother whose comedic routines took the place of sweeping the floor.
We live in a country where these two camps (rule abiders and breakers) exist, and I ask you this - - if the rule breakers weren't there, would we have the level of technological, financial, artistic, and athletic successes that we do today? If we impose more regulation, will individuals and groups still push, innovate, and progress? It is the rule breakers that advance the system, but the rule abiders that keep the current system productive and running smoothly. You need both and you need to manage both. However, the more we try to impose strict regulations on the entirety of the population, the less our society will grow. My parents were able to manage both camps. Some companies also manage the rule breakers and abiders very successfully. However, I think the nation's government is getting to the point, that might prove stifling to our collective progress. I ask though, how do you manage effectively on that grand of a scale?
My thoughts are exhausted at this point, but I would appreciate your comments and perspectives. Post away! For now, court adjourned!
Lo